Add another vehicle to compare side-by-side
View this comparison or add another vehicle
View this comparison now

Excellent driving, mediocre fuel-savings

2 Comments | Be the first to vote on this review
jaimebatiz on March 14, 2008 | Has owned a 2005 Honda Accord Hybrid Automatic

I bought this car brand new when the hype for hybrids (other than a Prius) was building up so that there was a waiting list. My previous car was a super-reliable 1998 Jetta (4-cilinders, manual transimission). I was very happy with the considerable jump in horsepowers in the Accord Hybrid, and the smooth driving. The interiors and exteriors are very pleasant in general. The car does look great!

My grievances in 'value' and 'performance' have to do with the whole concept of 'hybrid car' in Honda's technology. I guess I was expecting the same basic operation as with Toyota's hybrids: electric motor running at low or constant speeds. Instead, Honda uses the electric motor to assist the regular combustion engine while accelerating. The result is awesome acceleration, but no so much savings in fuel consumption specially if the car is driven short distances (3-5 miles) in local roads (up to 45MPH). Honda uses the batteries to do a neat fuel-saving trick: it completely stops the combustion engine if the car comes to a complete stop, and seamlessly restart its as soon as the break pedal is released. Although I appreciate this feature, it doesn't compensate for the fact that a lot more fuel would be saved by running exclusively with the electric engine.

I still get similar millage in this V6 engine than the 4-cilinder Jetta so not all is lost in terms of value.

At the time of purchase this car came with two expensive options: XM radio or Navigation. I couldn't chose "neither", but the Navigation was $2,000 extra so I got the XM radio which is now unused once the trial period expired.

California DMV decided that although this car is ULEV, it still is not eligible to drive on the carpool lanes. That was a medimum-sized disappointment.

Review 2005 Honda Accord Hybrid Automatic Excellent driving, mediocre fuel-savings

2005 Honda Accord Hybrid Automatic 2005 Honda Accord Hybrid Automatic

Review by jaimebatiz , March 14, 2008

Overall
Value
Comfort
Performance
Styling
Reliability
Flag
Did you find this review useful?

Comments for this review

Displaying 1-2 of 2 comments
  • Flag
    Brian Sy on March 15, 2008

    Good point; you actually touched upon that car's key flaw, and the reason it faded away after three years. People buy hybrids to save gas, not burn rubber.

  • Flag
    Stergios on March 15, 2008

    It is surprising to see how many cars now have the "Bricked" XM Radio in the dash. I know some people that barely listened while the free trail period was in effect, and now then when it expired it was a no-brainier to not shell out the money for it.

    You would think XM Radio would at least let you listen for free every once in a while, even after the free trial period. Say 30 free minutes a month. XM's marginal cost would be zero, and the probability that you might become a subscriber is much higher if you experience the product on a regular basis than never experiencing it at all.

* required